As the world of tabletop RPGs increasingly embraces digital tools and online platforms, game masters and players alike are seeking the best virtual tabletop (VTT) experience. Three of the top digital RPG tools on the market are Roll20, Fantasy Grounds, and Foundry VTT. In this blog post, we will compare these platforms in terms of their pros and cons, pricing, complexity of use, and the features they offer to users.
Roll20:
Roll20 is a popular web-based VTT platform that provides a wide range of tools for playing tabletop RPGs online. It supports various systems, including D&D, Pathfinder, and Call of Cthulhu.Pros:
Roll20's free tier makes it an accessible choice for players and game masters on a budget. This allows new users to try out the platform without any financial commitment. Another advantage of Roll20 is its browser-based interface, which requires no software installation and can be accessed from any device with an internet connection. The platform also has an extensive marketplace, where users can purchase additional assets such as maps, tokens, and modules to enhance their games. Additionally, Roll20 has built-in video and voice chat functionality, as well as text chat and customizable character sheets for various game systems.Cons:
One of the drawbacks of Roll20 is its learning curve, particularly when it comes to advanced features. New users may find it challenging to master the platform's more complex functionalities. Some users have also reported performance issues, especially when using large maps or intricate setups, which can detract from the gaming experience. Moreover, Roll20's dynamic lighting and other advanced features are only available through a subscription, which may be a barrier for some users.Complexity:
Roll20 is relatively easy to pick up for basic use but requires more time and effort to master advanced features.
Available Tools:
Dynamic lighting (for Pro subscribers), fog of war, integrated rulebooks, character sheets, dice rolling, macros, and API access (for Pro subscribers), extensive marketplace with official, third-party and user-generated material.
Price:
At the time of writing, Roll20 offers a free tier with basic features, a Plus subscription at $4.99/month, and a Pro subscription at $9.99/month.
Fantasy Grounds:
Fantasy Grounds is a powerful VTT platform available for Windows, macOS, and Linux, offering a robust set of tools for running tabletop RPGs online.Pros:
Fantasy Grounds' highly customizable interface sets it apart from other VTT platforms, allowing game masters to tailor the experience to their preferences. It also offers extensive support for various RPG systems and official rulebooks, with automation of rules and calculations to streamline gameplay. The active community and marketplace provide a wealth of user-generated content and official modules, allowing users to expand their games with new adventures and resources. Additionally, Fantasy Grounds offers one-time purchase options, which can provide long-term savings for dedicated users compared to subscription-based platforms.Cons:
The learning curve for Fantasy Grounds can be steep, especially for users who are new to VTT platforms or unfamiliar with advanced features. Unlike some other VTT platforms, Fantasy Grounds does not have built-in voice or video chat, which means that users must rely on third-party software for communication during games. The platform's graphics and interface may feel dated compared to newer VTT platforms, which could be a drawback for users seeking a more modern look and feel.Complexity:
Fantasy Grounds has a steeper learning curve due to its highly customizable interface and advanced features.
Available Tools:
Automated rules and calculations, character sheets, dynamic lighting, fog of war, map creation, dice rolling, and extensive library of official and user-generated content.
Price:
At the time of writing, Fantasy Grounds offers a monthly subscription at $3.99/month for players (Standard) and $9.99/month for GMs (Ultimate). One-time purchase options are available at $39 for Standard and $149 for Ultimate licenses.
Foundry VTT:
Foundry VTT is a relatively new VTT platform with a modern interface and a robust set of features, making it a strong contender in the market.
Pros:
Foundry VTT's modern, sleek interface sets it apart from other platforms, with a focus on ease of use and intuitive navigation. Its one-time purchase model with no subscription fees makes it a cost-effective option in the long run, particularly for users who plan to use the platform regularly. Foundry VTT benefits from active community-driven development, which means it receives frequent updates and improvements based on user feedback. The platform also has extensive modding support and API access, allowing users to customize their experience and add new features to suit their needs.Cons:
One drawback of Foundry VTT is the lack of built-in voice or video chat functionality. Like Fantasy Grounds, users need to rely on third-party software for communication during games. Another potential downside is that Foundry VTT may require more technical knowledge for installation and setup, especially if users choose to self-host the platform. This could be a barrier for less tech-savvy users or those who prefer a more straightforward setup process.Complexity:
Foundry VTT is designed with ease of use in mind, but may require some technical knowledge for installation and setup, especially for self-hosting.
Available Tools:
Modern interface, customizable character sheets, dynamic lighting, fog of war, map creation, dice rolling, extensive modding support, and API access.
Price:
At the time of writing, Foundry VTT is available as a one-time purchase of $50, with no subscription fees.
Conclusion:
Each of the three platforms—Roll20, Fantasy Grounds, and Foundry VTT—offers a unique set of features and capabilities to meet the diverse needs of the tabletop RPG community. Roll20 is an accessible, browser-based option with a free tier for those on a budget. Fantasy Grounds offers extensive customization and system support, making it ideal for dedicated users seeking a powerful VTT experience. Foundry VTT stands out with its modern interface and one-time purchase model, providing a cost-effective solution for long-term users.Ultimately, the best VTT platform for you will depend on your individual needs, preferences, and budget. By considering the pros and cons, pricing, complexity, and tools offered by each platform, you can make an informed decision and choose the best digital RPG tool for your gaming sessions.